Friday, 5 March 2021
No Result
View All Result
eudebates.tv
  • EU Policies
  • World
  • Special Debates
  • Events
  • Vote & Polls
eudebates.tv
No Result
View All Result
Home Debates EU Policies Enlargement and Foreign Affairs

Defence: Is the EU ready for a European army?

EUdebates Team by EUdebates Team
23/09/2019
in Enlargement and Foreign Affairs
0
EU Army European Defence Agency
12
SHARES
116
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Related posts

Asrar, 15, fled fighting in the Yemeni port city of Hodediah

EU humanitarian aid for Yemen threatened by conflict and famine

01/03/2021
President Charles Michel reiterated the European Union and President Maia Sandu in Moldova

President Charles Michel visited President Maia Sandu in Moldova

01/03/2021

Today a European army is far from a final deal. For the first time in decades, a window exists for Europe to take care of its own defence. The main problem comes down to different views of the European project. This is a problem. The formation of a European army is a common EU defence need, as the withdrawal of the U.S. empire from the continent.

Some, like the British, have always seen European Union is just an economic project first and foremost. Others have always seen it as a political project whose main aim is peace on the continent. For some the union is just a platform for cooperation between sovereign nation-states.

Why do we need a European Army?

Since 2016, there has been significant progress in the area of EU security and defence with several concrete EU initiatives to encourage cooperation and reinforce Europe’s capacity to defend itself.

Before every action comes the inspiration for it. So, what inspired the President of the French Republic and the German Chancellor to make a joint proclamation in November 2018 on the need for a European army, and then the Spanish head of government to join them a few weeks later? Did all three suddenly take leave of their senses?

Merkel and Macron want to create European military force

EU leaders realise that no EU country can tackle the current security threats in isolation. For example French President Macron called for a joint European military project in 2017, while German chancellor Merkel said “we ought to work on the vision of one day establishing a proper European army” in her address to the European Parliament in November 2018. Moving towards a security and defence union has been one of the priorities of the Juncker Commission.

Is it time for an EU Army?

While there is no EU army and defence remains exclusively a matter for member states, the EU has recently taken big steps to boost defence cooperation. The European army will be a largely meaningless project. A common EU defense policy is needed to be articulated to command the new European army. Unfortunately defence policy would have to be subordinate to EU foreign policy, and therefore also weak, dysfunctional, and fragmented.

High expectations for EU defence

Europeans expect the EU to guarantee security and peace. Three quarters (75%) are in favour of a common EU defence and security policy according to a special Eurobarometer on security and defence in 2017 and a majority (55%) were in favour of creating an EU army. More recently 68% of Europeans said they would like the EU to do more on defence (March 2018 Eurobarometer survey).

Most Europeans want the EU to do more to boost security and defence
Most Europeans want the EU to do more to boost security and defence

Apart from practical challenges, the EU needs to reconcile different traditions and different strategic cultures. The EU Parliament believes that an EU white paper on defence would be a useful way to do it and underpin the development of a future EU defence policy.

Recent EU measures to boost defence cooperation

A common EU defence policy is provided for by the Treaty of Lisbon (Article 42(2) TEU). However, the treaty also clearly states the importance of national defence policy, including NATO membership or neutrality.

In recent years, the EU has begun to implement ambitious initiatives to provide more resources, stimulate efficiency, facilitate cooperation and support the development of capabilities:

Permanent Structured Cooperation (PESCO) was launched in December 2017, and 25 EU countries are participating as of June 2019. It currently operates on the basis of 34 concrete projects with binding commitments including a European Medical Command, Maritime Surveillance System, mutual assistance for cyber-security and rapid response teams, and a Joint EU intelligence school.

The European Defence Fund (EDF) was launched in June 2017. It is the first time the EU budget is used to co-fund defence cooperation and the fund should be part of the EU’s next long-term budget (2021-2027). EDF will complement national investments and provide both practical and financial incentives for collaborative research, joint development and acquisition of defence equipment and technology.

EDF – European Defense Fund

The E.U.’s next seven-year budget has €20 billion earmarked for defense overall. That spending includes €13 billion for the European Defence Fund to cover the E.U.’s 2021-2027 financial period, proposed by the European Commission last June and approved by the Parliament earlier this month.

EU strengthened cooperation with NATO in 74 areas including cybersecurity, joint exercises and counter-terrorism. A plan to facilitate military mobility within and across the EU to make it possible for military personnel and equipment to act faster in response to crises.

Making the financing of civilian and military missions and operations more effective. The EU currently has 16 such missions on three continents, with a wide range of mandates and deploying more than 6,000 civilian and military personnel. Since June 2017 there is a new command and control structure (MPCC) to improve the EU’s crisis management.

EU army to complement NATO

By contrast, even if NATO has strengthened its conventional deterrent capability, it remains largely unqualified to respond to hybrid, diffuse threats.

This is not an army against NATO, it can be a good complement to NATO.
Angela Merkel Chancellor of Germany

WHY THE EU NEEDS A COMMON ARMY?

In the past years, the possibilities for EU Member States to cooperate in the field of foreign and security policy have been extended significantly. In some cases, Member States jointly sent soldiers and experts abroad on a mission. A true European army, like the German Bundeswehr, does not exist on the EU level. But that’s exactly what JEF is calling for, so that the EU can act faster and more efficiently.

Evolution of European foreign policy

Historically, we have seen some slow changes in the field of European foreign policy. In recent years we have had some good examples of a coordinated, common approach to Foreign Policy issues under the leadership of Federica Mogherini. Without a doubt, one of her main achievements was, the Nuclear deal with Iran. A perfect example of how a unison European voice can influence the world for the better. However, in the case of Ukraine, the analysis is a bit different.

Security Structure

Ursula von der Leyen has claimed that a legal framework now exists for a European Defence Union. President elect Ursula von der Leyen -previous German Defence Minister- has mentioned that it’s about time to develop a structure that tells Europeans when to use their “forces”.

We must become more European. I see many areas where NATO is not in demand, for example, the whole Africa topic.
Ursula von der Leyen

Italy’s government said last week that it is ready to join a European military coalition to react to crises near the continent’s borders. It described the European Intervention Initiative as “an innovative approach to cooperation in defense, inspired by the ideas of political interoperability and strategic anticipation.”

European Intervention Initiative – EI2

The idea behind EI2 is to develop the capability to rapidly deploy on joint military operations, civilian evacuations, or disaster relief.

Belgium, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, Germany, the Netherlands, Portugal, Spain and the United Kingdom have signed up to the French-led initiative.

The European Intervention Initiative (EI2) is a joint military project between 12 European countries.It is an initiative outside of existing structures, such as the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) and the European Union’s (EU) defence arm. EI2 is planned to operate a “light” permanent secretariat based on the network of military liaison officers with the French defence ministry.

EU tensions with the United States

The drive to increase European defense funding has caused some tensions with Washington – White House. Officials fear U.S. defense companies may be shut out of E.U. projects.

Is Europe finally ready for an army?

Demands for it are getting louder than ever.

Europeans are under great pressure. Major crises are driving this push for a European military. That is why it must be taken seriously, despite all past failed rhetoric. Terrorist attacks, the migrant crisis, Russia’s increasing aggression—none of these are going away.

Share this debate with your friends!
Follow #eudebates on Google News and on Facebook
Tags: Angela MerkelARMYBordersCommon Security and Defence PolicyCross Border CooperationCybersecurityDEFENCEDG DefenceEmmanuel MacronEU ArmyEU BordersEU-USAEurobarometerEuropean ArmyEuropean ParliamentEuropean Security and DefenceExternal bordersFederica MogheriniForeign AffairsFrench PresidentJean-Claude JunckerMERKELMiddle East SecurityNATOOTANPARLIAMENTPeaceRussiaSecuritySecurity PolicySecurity UnionUrsula von der LeyenUSA
Share5Tweet3

Related EU debates

Asrar, 15, fled fighting in the Yemeni port city of Hodediah
Enlargement and Foreign Affairs

EU humanitarian aid for Yemen threatened by conflict and famine

01/03/2021
President Charles Michel reiterated the European Union and President Maia Sandu in Moldova
Enlargement and Foreign Affairs

President Charles Michel visited President Maia Sandu in Moldova

01/03/2021
Portuguese Presidency of the Council of the European Union
Enlargement and Foreign Affairs

EU extends sanctions against Lukashenko in Belarus for a year

27/02/2021
Jens STOLTENBERG, Secretary General of NATO and Charles MICHEL, President of the European Council
Enlargement and Foreign Affairs

Strategic autonomy, security and EU self-defense role with NATO

27/02/2021
A Military airplane from Bucharest, Romania arrives in Milan, Italy bringing in DPI protections, part of Operation RescEU in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic
Enlargement and Foreign Affairs

EU sends emergency medical teams to Slovakia and masks to Serbia

24/02/2021
Ursula von der Leyen President of the European Commission
Enlargement and Foreign Affairs

President von der Leyen eudebates Global Citizen’s global recovery

22/02/2021

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

What is Pay Transparency and why it matters?

What is Pay Transparency and why it matters?

04/03/2021
FEMM Committee - Inter-parliamentary Committee Meeting - International Women’s Day 2021 ' We are strong: Women leading the fight against Covid-19 '

Gender Equality: Recovery plans must support more women to top positions

04/03/2021
Paolo Gentiloni fiscal policy

EU fiscal rules and the way out of the pandemic

04/03/2021
wheelchair for Person with Disabilities

EU Strategy for the Rights of Persons with Disabilities 2021-2030

04/03/2021
EU flag

New EU investment priorities of €330 billion cohesion legislative package

04/03/2021
Dubrovnik Croatia

Croatia improves drinking water and treatment system in Dubrovnik

02/03/2021
  • Nigel Farage

    EU nasty and vindictive? Nigel Farage criticizes EU vaccines strategy

    68 shares
    Share 27 Tweet 17
  • EU: AstraZeneca logic can only work at the neighbourhood butchers

    48 shares
    Share 19 Tweet 12
  • Barnier: Brexit shows the EU is not a prison after EU-UK Trade Deal

    35 shares
    Share 14 Tweet 9
  • After Brexit will the UK lose the Falkland Islands?

    35 shares
    Share 14 Tweet 9
  • Portugal plans 2021 Year Europe’s recovery, cohesion and values

    34 shares
    Share 14 Tweet 9
What is Pay Transparency and why it matters?

What is Pay Transparency and why it matters?

04/03/2021
FEMM Committee - Inter-parliamentary Committee Meeting - International Women’s Day 2021 ' We are strong: Women leading the fight against Covid-19 '

Gender Equality: Recovery plans must support more women to top positions

04/03/2021
Paolo Gentiloni fiscal policy

EU fiscal rules and the way out of the pandemic

04/03/2021
wheelchair for Person with Disabilities

EU Strategy for the Rights of Persons with Disabilities 2021-2030

04/03/2021
EU flag

New EU investment priorities of €330 billion cohesion legislative package

04/03/2021
Dubrovnik Croatia

Croatia improves drinking water and treatment system in Dubrovnik

02/03/2021
eudebates.tv

Welcome to eudebates.tv the unique european initiative to promote debate, dialogue and communication among citizens for a better Europe.

Follow us on social media:

Recent News

  • What is Pay Transparency and why it matters?
  • Gender Equality: Recovery plans must support more women to top positions
  • EU fiscal rules and the way out of the pandemic
  • EU Strategy for the Rights of Persons with Disabilities 2021-2030
  • New EU investment priorities of €330 billion cohesion legislative package

Newsletter

Join our newsletter!

Enter your email to receive our newsletter.

Don't worry, we don't spam
What is Pay Transparency and why it matters?

What is Pay Transparency and why it matters?

04/03/2021
FEMM Committee - Inter-parliamentary Committee Meeting - International Women’s Day 2021 ' We are strong: Women leading the fight against Covid-19 '

Gender Equality: Recovery plans must support more women to top positions

04/03/2021
Paolo Gentiloni fiscal policy

EU fiscal rules and the way out of the pandemic

04/03/2021
  • Home
  • EU Policies
  • Special Debates
  • Events
  • Vote & Polls
  • Video

© 2021 eudebates - EU debates, dialogue, communication for a better Europe - Privacy Policy.

No Result
View All Result
  • EU Policies
  • World
  • Special Debates
  • Events
  • Vote & Polls

© 2021 eudebates - EU debates, dialogue, communication for a better Europe - Privacy Policy.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist